Properties

Sorted by

812 Cold Spring Ave

The Blue Whale Beach House Cute and convenient, dog-friendly rental home on the island! This...

The Blue Whale Beach House Cute and convenient, dog-friendly rental home on the island! This 2-bedroom cottage is nestled in a quiet neighborhood straight up...

6
2
1
$ 225-2000 per wk/nt
$ 225-2000 per wk/nt
6
2
1

227 Windsor Avenue

“The Windsor House” Surround yourself with the ambiance of Victorian Charm in Cape May. Enjoy...

“The Windsor House” Surround yourself with the ambiance of Victorian Charm in Cape May. Enjoy a completely renovated home in the heart of town. Experience...

4
2.5
$6,300.00 per week
$6,300.00 per week
4
2.5

610 Madison Ave

This cheerful single-family home is in walking distance of the beach and Cape May’s Washington...

This cheerful single-family home is in walking distance of the beach and Cape May’s Washington Street Mall. There are 3 bedrooms on the first floor....

7
4
2
$ 300-3465 per nt/wk
$ 300-3465 per nt/wk
7
4
2

1520 New Jersey Ave Unit 325

Located at Cape Roc Condo in the sought after ‘Poverty Beach’ section of Cape May....

Located at Cape Roc Condo in the sought after ‘Poverty Beach’ section of Cape May. Unit 325 top floor unobstructed view from bedroom. Custom Cape...

5
1
1
$ 250-2700 per Nt/Wk
$ 250-2700 per Nt/Wk
5
1
1

1016 Illinois Ave.

 Charming Beach House Charming beach house complete with everything you could ask for on your...

 Charming Beach House Charming beach house complete with everything you could ask for on your summer vacation. Clean, comfortable, and conveniently located 8-1/2 blocks from...

8
3
2
$ 350-3600 per nt/wk
$ 350-3600 per nt/wk
8
3
2

201 Beach Avenue, Unit 9

Direct Unobstructed Ocean View & Heated Pool! Available 2026 Sat. to Sat. for Weeks 5-23,...

Direct Unobstructed Ocean View & Heated Pool! Available 2026 Sat. to Sat. for Weeks 5-23, 5-30, 6-20, 6-29, 8-29 & 9-5! Reserve Now for Spring...

8
4
4.5
$ $4.5K to $9.0K per week
$ $4.5K to $9.0K per week
8
4
4.5

907 Stockton Ave – Magnolia Porch

Only one block to the beach with huge front porch and yard! Perfect for multi-generational...

Only one block to the beach with huge front porch and yard! Perfect for multi-generational family groups. Make memories at the Magnolia Porch this year!...

16
7
5 plus 2 outdoor showers
16,324 per week
16,324 per week
16
7
5 plus 2 outdoor showers

722 Corgie Street

722 Corgie Street-Newly Renovated 7-bedroom Victorian in the heart of Cape May Welcome to Corgie...

722 Corgie Street-Newly Renovated 7-bedroom Victorian in the heart of Cape May Welcome to Corgie House (722 Corgie Street) in the heart of historic Cape...

18
7
3
1000-13000 Per nt/wk
1000-13000 Per nt/wk
18
7
3

14 Second Ave 1st Floor

Within mere steps of the beach, this spacious first-floor 3 bedroom 2 bath condo is...

Within mere steps of the beach, this spacious first-floor 3 bedroom 2 bath condo is the ideal summer or off-season retreat! Cape May’s popular Cove...

9
3
1
$ 295-4100 per nt/wk
$ 295-4100 per nt/wk
9
3
1

420 Broadway Full House

8 bedrooms, 6 full bathrooms. Large property featuring two large 4-bedroom units that can be...

8 bedrooms, 6 full bathrooms. Large property featuring two large 4-bedroom units that can be rented together or separately. Total occupancy is 20+. Both units...

20
8
6
$ 400-7300 per nt/wk
$ 400-7300 per nt/wk
20
8
6

129 Eldredge Ave

Welcome to Seashells Located just a short walk to Cape May’s prettiest beach, the Cove,...

Welcome to Seashells Located just a short walk to Cape May’s prettiest beach, the Cove, and some amazing restaurants and the Washington Street Pedestrian Mall,...

8
4
2.5
$ 3500-4400 per week
$ 3500-4400 per week
8
4
2.5

34 Jackson Street

Best Location! Have it All: Beach, Shops, Porch, and Parking! Once you’ve arrived, there’s no...

Best Location! Have it All: Beach, Shops, Porch, and Parking! Once you’ve arrived, there’s no need for a car…you’re exactly where you want to be...

4
3
$ 800-5750 per week
$ 800-5750 per week
4
3

846 Broadway, Unit B

2025 – 2026 Rental Rates Condo Unit B October 2025 through April 2026 (2-night minimum) –...

2025 – 2026 Rental Rates Condo Unit B October 2025 through April 2026 (2-night minimum) – $232 weekday/night         –  $250 weekends/night Both...

4
1
1
$ 232-250 per night
$ 232-250 per night
4
1
1

820 Sewell Avenue

Perfectly Situated, Completely Updated 1920s Colonial This completely remodeled and updated home is located in...

Perfectly Situated, Completely Updated 1920s Colonial This completely remodeled and updated home is located in the heart of Cape May, just blocks from Jefferson Street...

10-12
5
3.5
$ 625 - 9,160 per nt, per wk
$ 625 - 9,160 per nt, per wk
10-12
5
3.5

118 Decatur Street 118 Decatur Street

King’s Landing Best location: half a block to the beach and half a block to...

King’s Landing Best location: half a block to the beach and half a block to Washington Mall. Welcome to 118 Decatur This historic 1885 Victorian...

20
8
5.5
15,000 per week
15,000 per week
20
8
5.5

234 Fourth Avenue

Charming two-story home perfectly situated just a short stroll or bike ride to Cape May’s...

Charming two-story home perfectly situated just a short stroll or bike ride to Cape May’s beautiful beaches, iconic Congress Hall, Beach Plum Farm, Willow Creek...

9
4
1.5
$ 3200-3500 per week
$ 3200-3500 per week
9
4
1.5

1105 Pittsburgh Ave $

Perfectly blending modern accommodations and the beach, this five-bedroom, four-and-a-half-bathroom, three-story property makes another brilliant...

Perfectly blending modern accommodations and the beach, this five-bedroom, four-and-a-half-bathroom, three-story property makes another brilliant addition to this fantastic new development, and the homeowners have...

12
5
4.5
1000-11000 per we/nt
1000-11000 per we/nt
12
5
4.5

1520 New York Ave

This beautiful home is located in the Poverty Beach section of town. With over 5,000+...

This beautiful home is located in the Poverty Beach section of town. With over 5,000+ feet of living space, it is the perfect home for...

14
5
5.5
$ 5950 - 9000 per week
$ 5950 - 9000 per week
14
5
5.5

316 Jefferson Street

Welcome to Sip~n~Chat Cottage This beautiful Classic Cape May home was built in 1920. Once...

Welcome to Sip~n~Chat Cottage This beautiful Classic Cape May home was built in 1920. Once you arrive,  just park (up to four )cars in your...

10
4
3
$ 600-6300 per nt/wk
$ 600-6300 per nt/wk
10
4
3

301 Frances Avenue

Pet-Friendly 301 Frances Avenue is a beautiful Delaware Bay beachfront home. Enjoy vacationing in this...

Pet-Friendly 301 Frances Avenue is a beautiful Delaware Bay beachfront home. Enjoy vacationing in this contemporary home nestled in the sand dunes of the popular...

6
3
2
$ 475-4200 per nt/wk
$ 475-4200 per nt/wk
6
3
2

413 Jefferson Street

Welcome to the Craftsman Cottage! Newly renovated and restored classic Cape May Craftsman-style cottage.  The...

Welcome to the Craftsman Cottage! Newly renovated and restored classic Cape May Craftsman-style cottage.  The house is centrally located, only 17 houses away from the...

12
5
3
550-7500 $ per nt/wk
550-7500 $ per nt/wk
12
5
3

119 Town Bank Rd

Luxury cottage walkable to the beach and Harpoon’s on the Bay. “Amazing stay! The house...

Luxury cottage walkable to the beach and Harpoon’s on the Bay. “Amazing stay! The house is beautiful and impeccable. We definitely recommend booking!” Fully-equipped kitchen...

6
2
2
$ 2000-2995 per week
$ 2000-2995 per week
6
2
2

606 Cape Avenue

Cozy quiet cottage in Cape May Point, NJ just 5 blocks from the beaches, bird...

Cozy quiet cottage in Cape May Point, NJ just 5 blocks from the beaches, bird sanctuary, and lighthouse. Two stories have 8 beds, 1 sofa...

4
1.5
$ 850-1775 per week
$ 850-1775 per week
4
1.5

1520 Yacht Avenue Unit 104

Luxury holiday retreat in Cape May’s Marina District. Experience coastal elegance at this newly renovated...

Luxury holiday retreat in Cape May’s Marina District. Experience coastal elegance at this newly renovated 2-bedroom, 2-bath luxury condo in the highly sought-after Devil’s Reach...

6
2
2
per nt/wk
per nt/wk
6
2
2

711 Broadway

Pet-Friendly Restored farmhouse located in West Cape May. A large driveway for private parking can...

Pet-Friendly Restored farmhouse located in West Cape May. A large driveway for private parking can accommodate up to 5 cars. Large fenced-in yard and pet-friendly....

8
3
1.5
$3,400.00 Per Week
$3,400.00 Per Week
8
3
1.5

309 First Avenue

Pool, Lighthouse, Ocean, and Sunset Views!!! Beautiful, Resort like, 3 story New Construction Home Features:...

Pool, Lighthouse, Ocean, and Sunset Views!!! Beautiful, Resort like, 3 story New Construction Home Features: 5 Bedrooms  Sleeps 12 4 1/2 Baths 2 Living areas...

12
5
4.5
10,00-14,500 per week
10,00-14,500 per week
12
5
4.5

205 Perry Street

Welcome to 205 Perry Street! Our 6-bedroom, 4-bath historic home is in the heart of...

Welcome to 205 Perry Street! Our 6-bedroom, 4-bath historic home is in the heart of Cape May. Our beautiful Mall block beach home has been...

12
6
4
900-15,900 $ per nt/wk
900-15,900 $ per nt/wk
12
6
4

501 Oak Avenue

Our Summer Place at the Point located in idyllic Cape May Point has been renovated...

Our Summer Place at the Point located in idyllic Cape May Point has been renovated with a new addition for a totally relaxing and stress-free...

4
2.5
$2,890.00 per week
$2,890.00 per week
4
2.5