122 Eldredge Avenue

Experience Coastal Comfort, Historic Charm, and Modern Luxury

Beautiful, meticulously remodeled 5-bedroom Victorian home dating back to 1870 in the heart of Cape May, just blocks from the beach and within easy walking distance to Washington Street Mall and all of Cape May’s restaurants and attractions. Central air-conditioning keeps warm days cool, while baseboard heating and a brand-new indoor gas fireplace add warmth and ambiance during Cape May’s crisp autumns and cozy winters.

At the center of the house is a sprawling, modern eat-in kitchen. The space comfortably seats 12 and features custom cabinets, new appliances, hardwood floors, quartz countertops, and a large quartz island.

The home’s generous layout offers myriad places to gather and relax, including a sun room with panoramic windows and plush seating, a spacious library and game room, and a living room with ample seating and large-screen television above the mantle. A new half-bath on the main floor adds convenience for guests, while the wide front porch with comfortable furniture invites you to watch the world go by. Parking is never a concern thanks to the new brick and shell driveway that accommodates up to 3 cars with ease.

What truly sets the house apart is it’s expansive double-lot backyard. Elegant landscaping frames multiple seating areas and the custom-built pavilion shelters an outdoor kitchen and bar. With a sparkling pool, large patio, lush lawn, and a fire-pit surrounded by Adirondack chairs, the backyard is a playground for all ages. An outdoor shower completes the resort-like experience.

Upstairs, the second floor offers 3 fully-renovated bedrooms that promise restorative comfort. The oversized primary bedroom features a king-size bed, generous walk-in closet, and a modern en suite bath with spa-like features. A large-screen television ensures private entertainment while coastal-inspired decor infuses the space with tranquility.

Two additional second-floor bedrooms each offer queen-size beds and spacious closets. These rooms share a stylish jack-and-jill bathroom designed for privacy and ease.

The third floor provides two more bedrooms – one with a queen-size bed and another featuring two twin beds. All bedrooms are tastefully decorated, drawing inspiration from the nearby shore with soft hues and seaside motifs.

2025 Rental Rates

3 night minimum October 2025 through April 2026 ($500/night) with the exception of the following holiday weeks:
Thanksgiving: $750/night
Christmas (5-night minimum): $750/night

$500 refundable security deposit
$300 cleaning fee

*Pet-friendly for a single dog under 20 pounds $300